The Timeless Charm of Mackinac Island

Fran Miller

Often listed among the top summer destinations in the United States—Mackinac Island is an Americana fantasy come to life. Nestled within Lake Huron, between Michigan’s Upper and Lower Peninsulas, its nearly four square miles have long captivated visitors with its timeless charm, picturesque landscapes and quaint atmosphere—largely due to its absence of motor vehicles.

The island’s history is as vibrant as its beautiful coastal landscapes. Originally inhabited by Native American tribes, particularly the Odawa and Ojibwe, the first European visitors (French explorers and missionaries) arrived in the 17th century. The island became a pivotal military outpost during the War of 1812, serving as a base for American and British forces. In the late 19th century, the island transitioned from a military stronghold to a summer resort destination for wealthy families, leading to the construction of grand hotels and the preservation of its historic sites. Today, visitors ferry over from Mackinaw City for day trips or longer leisurely stays that reveal the island’s multiple treasures.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: SIX PLACES FOR STUNNING FALL FOLIAGE | FALL LEAVES TRAVEL GUIDE

Fran Miller

Where to Stay:

The stately Grand Hotel might be Mackinac Island’s hotel icon, but it is the newly remodeled The Inn at Stonecliffe that is capturing the imaginations of those seeking something a bit off the beaten path. A 45-minute bucolic carriage ride from the hustle and bustle of the island’s Main St., gracious Stonecliffe is an ICONIC property built in 1904 as a private lakeside estate.
After two years and a more than $40-million property-wide transformation, Stonecliffe debuted this past summer with a new look and elevated hospitality offerings. The 15-acre property boasts expansive common spaces, new guestrooms, multiple food and beverage offerings, a state-of-the-art fitness center, an apple orchard and the glorious, sprawling Straits Lawn over which an enormous American flag waves in the wind.

Stonecliffe’s stately 18,500-square-foot mansion has been lovingly restored to include 16 modern guestrooms, each unique in décor. An adjacent summer house boasts 32 guest rooms adorned with artwork by local artisans. For a bit more room, three impeccably designed private cottages with fully equipped kitchens are an excellent choice for families. Two swimming pools (one for families and one for adults), a bicycle pavilion offering bikes for rent, and abundant activities mean that guests do not need to leave the property to enjoy the best of the island.

Fran Miller

What to Do:

Rent a Stonecliffe bicycle and hit the eight-mile, car-free M-185 highway that encircles the island. It’s the only state highway in the United States where motor vehicles are prohibited; the views of Lake Huron and the surrounding landscapes are breathtaking.

No visit is complete without indulging in the local tradition of a horse-drawn carriage ride. If you are a guest at Stonecliffe, you’ll enjoy the experience en route to and from the property.

Indulge in Mackinac Island’s most significant export: fudge. Main St. teems with fudge shops, but Murdick’s Fudge is the island OG. Founded in 1887 and still family-owned, Murdick’s continues to utilize the same recipes (all natural ingredients) and paddling techniques as those of founder Mrs. Henry Murdick. Visitors can watch the experts at work.

Enjoy a Rum Runner at The Pink Pony. If fudge is the island’s most famous culinary item, The Pink Pony Rum Runner is the libation equivalent. Featuring a refreshing blend of rum and fruit juices, the Rum Runner reflects the island’s laid-back vacation vibe. Enjoyed on The Pink Pony’s back deck with harbor views, the potent cocktail makes for a memorable Mackinac Island experience.

Book a cruise around the island with Brown Eyed Girl Charters, and explore the island from the surrounding crystal clear waters. Captain Alan will drop anchor if weather permits, allowing you a quick dip in chilly Lake Huron.

Explore Mackinac Island State Park. More than 80% of the island is a protected state park, offering hiking trails, stunning vistas and opportunities for horseback riding.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: LAKE COMO’S GRAND HOTEL VILLA SERBELLONI EXUDES THROWBACK GLAMOUR

Fran Miller

Relax with a good book. The charming Mackinac Island library, located at the end of Main St. in a historic building, primarily serves the island’s residents. Yet, visitors are welcome to browse and use the facilities. The library is situated near the harbor and features a patio with Adirondack chairs poised towards the water.

Take a watercolor class. The island is an artist’s paradise, as evidenced by Stonecliffe’s vast display of works by local artisans. Stonecliffe offers classes with local watercolor artist Kate Dupre, the creative force behind the island’s popular and charming Watercolor Café.

Catch a golden sunset atop Sunset Rock. Stonecliffe provides easy path access to this ICONIC island outcropping, which affords gorgeous panoramic dusk views.

Fran Miller

Where to Dine:

At any vacation destination, it’s often wise to follow the locals, and on Mackinac Island, you’ll find them enjoying the dining options at Stonecliffe. The fine-dining restaurant, The Straits, serves local specialties from Michigan and the Great Lakes with ingredients sourced from the resort’s orchard and garden. The lovely formal dining room overlooks the Straits Lawn.

For something more casual, The Backyard features various wood-fired pizzas served al fresco on a brick patio. And Horsey’s Bar is a cozy spot for crafted cocktails and small bites.

Whatever your meal choice, save room for homemade ice cream scooped from the cooler at The General Store. Look to Woods Restaurant & Bobby’s Bar for something off-property, just a short stroll from Stonecliffe. Reminiscent of a Bavarian hunting lodge, the menu features hearty comfort food. Be sure to look beyond the bar for the single-lane bowling alley. Originally constructed in 1898, it is one of the oldest surviving bowling alleys in the nation.

Fran Miller

Mackinac Island is a step back in time. It’s a place to leave worries behind. (And a place of trust where bike locks are unnecessary.) Every interaction feels like a reunion with old friends. The island’s sights, sounds and scents (fudge!) evoke a sense of nostalgia, making it a truly magical experience.

Owned by the Pulte Family Charitable Foundation, The Inn at Stonecliffe is one of three Humanitarian Hotels with 100% of net profits being used to support charitable initiatives (scholarship programs, homeless shelters, soup kitchens, affordable housing, mental health, and more) in Mackinac County and around the globe.